Okay so i don't know how hard it is to make weapon models but...
In retail there was a weapon costume slot. Now i know i alot of these weapon costumes were turned into actual weapons that drop from livid.. so here i am to suggest this instead... now i haven't come up with a list of what all weapon costumes their could be and though there is a lot of what i'd like to do i avoided the ones that could cause "Copyright issues" i don't know how big that issue would be with no scrubs... anyway my list of things that could be done about this.
First off: stats. This is a big one i guess... attack, defense, cast time, attack speed. stats. the normal stuff for costume stuff?
My list is as follows. Note some items are missing... i can't think of good things for it...
1H sword: Baseball bat, Tennis racket? meat cleaver (Y'know butcher knife), pirate's cutlass
2 H sword: A scythe, a mace, or wanna get really bad a 2x4 with nails ahaha, Or better yet a lamp post
dual swords: Several items crossed my mind here, but most were just repeats of other stuff... and that got boring.. aka Two baseball bats etc etc.only thing i could really come up for here that would be different might be... two guitars. But really anything for one hand sword can go for duals
Sheild: I'm sorry my mind went blank i can't think of anything Stuff will come to me though..
Gun: This is fairly simple: A civil war style rifle. A thompson tommy gun, on a lighter note:a water gun
Daggers: ORGINALLY i wanted to suggest a pair of wrist mounted blades, but then i realized i've been playing Assassin's creed to much. So i came up with a better idea. nightsticks. Tonfas. y'know the long black sticks with a handle that juts out int he middle. could even do two sharp slivers of glass AHAHA
staffs: again i had a REALLY hard time with this as well... : Get rid of the staff and have a floatting orb of energy only? Or maybe a tome they hold in their hands like a spell caster? i can't think of much here...
Anyway so i don't know how hard this would be to impliment but i know the weapon costume does still have a place since the slot is there for it in the AH... just a suggestion